The Diminishing Returns of Materialism : Chasing Possessions or True Fulfilment?

5 Minute Read:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is public_domain_fear-1024x727-1.jpeg

As we grow, one prevailing theme becomes increasingly evident: our quest for financial security often leads us down a path of acquiring more expensive possessions rather than true fulfilment. While it’s true that, in our youth, we had limited financial resources, we often look back on those times with nostalgia, recalling them as happy and carefree. However, as we age and become financially independent, we might find ourselves no happier and, in fact, often less content than we were in our younger, less affluent days. This essay explores why this paradox exists and how the pursuit of material possessions can impact our well-being.

As we transition into adulthood, we enter the workforce, earning salaries and accumulating financial resources. It is at this juncture that many of us fall into the materialism trap. According to a study by the American Psychological Association (APA), the more money we earn, the more our desires expand, leading us to crave more expensive and luxurious items: a better car, a bigger house, multiple vacations, designer clothing, and so on. This insatiable desire for more often pushes us to take on credits and debt, or work even harder to gain promotion in the workplace, all in the name of maintaining a particular lifestyle.”

However, what ensues is not an increase in happiness but rather a heightened level of stress. According to the concept of ‘Affluenza,’ the pressure to earn more money to sustain our lifestyles weighs heavily on our lives and relationships.

Fears of job insecurity, financial crises, and rising interest rates add to our anxieties. We become slaves to our desires, chained to a lifestyle that, paradoxically, often diminishes our sense of contentment.

In various cultures around the world, the approach to materialism and its consequences may differ significantly. For example, in Eastern cultures like Japan and many parts of Southeast Asia, there is a strong influence of philosophies such as Zen Buddhism, which emphasise simplicity, minimalism, and the pursuit of inner peace. These cultures often place a greater emphasis on relationships, community, and the intangible aspects of life rather than material wealth.

In contrast, Western societies, particularly in the United States and Europe, have often embraced consumerism and the pursuit of material success as central values. The accumulation of possessions, career achievements, and financial prosperity are frequently prioritized, contributing to a culture where desires for material gain are heavily emphasised.

This cultural perspective highlights how societal values can shape individual attitudes toward materialism. It shows that the materialism trap can be especially challenging to break free from in cultures that place a strong emphasis on consumerism and the pursuit of material wealth.

Understanding the trap of materialism and the fleeting happiness it offers can be the first step towards building a more meaningful life. The concept of the hedonic treadmill reveals our human tendency to quickly adapt to changes in circumstances, including the acquisition of material possessions. It suggests that while we may initially experience a surge in happiness when we attain something we desire, this boost is transient. As we become accustomed to our new possessions or circumstances, our baseline level of happiness reverts to its original state. This phenomenon underscores the idea that the relentless pursuit of material wealth often leads to a never-ending cycle of desire, ultimately failing to provide long-lasting contentment. Recognising the hedonic treadmill encourages us to seek fulfilment in more enduring sources like experiences and relationships.

While it’s true that material possessions can provide a sense of comfort and security, it’s essential to recognise that they may offer only a temporary and limited form of solace. Many studies indicate that there is a threshold beyond which additional income or possessions have diminishing returns in terms of happiness and well-being.

Moreover, placing excessive emphasis on material wealth as a source of comfort can lead to a misplaced sense of security, particularly when one’s happiness becomes overwhelmingly tied to the accumulation of possessions or job promotions. In contrast, focusing on building a more fulfilling life through experiences, relationships, and personal growth often yields a more lasting and profound sense of security. Embracing simplicity and mindfulness can help individuals find a balance that prioritises both security and true fulfilment in a world that is ever-changing and unpredictable. Ultimately, true happiness may be found not in the accumulation of material possessions or workplace promotions, but in the experiences and connections that enrich our lives.

In conclusion, our pursuit of wealth often leads us into the materialism trap. However, by incorporating – statistics, historical and cultural perspectives, psychological insights, and addressing counterarguments – we can build a more compelling and engaging argument. By recognising the pitfalls of materialism, we can seek a more fulfilling and meaningful life, unburdened by the never-ending desire for possessions and status.

Written by Stephen Griffin and ChatGPT



Leave a comment

About Me

I am fascinated by the extensive body of work developed by Tom Campbell, and have found his My Big TOE (Theory of Everything) theory to be particularly insightful in exploring fundamental questions that have puzzled mankind throughout history. Utilizing Campbell’s theories, my goal is to gain a deeper understanding of not only myself, but also others and the world around me. By examining these concepts through the lens of MBT, I believe we can unlock a greater understanding of our collective existence and the nature of reality itself.

Yesterday I was clever, so I wanted to change the world. Today, I am wise so I am changing myself.” –Rumi.

¨The day science begins to study non-physical phenomena, it will make more progress in one decade than in all the previous centuries of its existence.¨ Nikola Tesla.

Newsletter